Keith Herrington
Meet the Team
The Keith Herrington Team
Testimonials
"
Mr. Keith Herrington provided the most incredible, over-the-top service throughout the home selling process. We are so very blessed and thankful for Mr. Herrington exceeding our expectations from start to finish.
"
- Barbara Shultz
"
Keith walked us seamlessly through the process of selling our parents home.
"
- Norma Headlee/Estate
"
His excellent communication! I never had to wait for a call or email from Keith. He was in constant contact with me from the beginning of our listing to the date of our closing. This is such an important characteristic to me, and Keith continually exceeded my expectations
"
- Kathleen Doody
"
Keith Herrington is a true professional and he made a difficult situation (selling a home from 1,000 miles away) easy. He went out of his way to meet me at the house the day I called so that I didn’t have to extend my stay, and took care of all the details. After the house was listed, Keith answered our questions promptly, and communicated with us every step of the process. We were able to sell the home quickly for the full asking price, and I would definitely recommend Keith!
"
- Robert Sellers Estate
"
Keith went above and beyond to get us out home. He communicated with us daily even with the smallest details. We can't thank him enough for helping and guiding us through the home buying/selling process!
"
- Scott & Bethany Fraley
"
He explained everything each step of the way. He kept me informed and was always accessible. He has sold two homes for me and I would give him the highest recommendation.
"
- R.A.M.
"
Keith is honest, upfront & very easy to work with.
"
- M.I.
"
Keith was extremely thorough and made the sale of our home much easier than we thought. Keith was highly recommended to us and we would do the same for anyone needing his services. We give him a rating of 10++.
"
- Barbara M. Troutman
"
5 Star Review
"
- J.W.K.
"
Keith is very professional and has a lot of integrity. He was very timely with any texts, emails and etc
"
- Penny Ketchem
"
I couldn't have found a better agent then Keith. He really worked hard to make everything in the sale of my home go smoothly. When buying my new home, he was so helpful and fought tooth and nail to get me the best deal. I will recommend him highly to anyone buying or selling a home. He even called after I moved to check if everything was fine or I needed anything else.
"
- L.C.
"
Keith is very kind, compassionate, and responsive. I felt taken care of and that my best interests were his priority. From start to finish, he was there for me to answer any questions and ease my mind in purchasing my home. He is insightful, trustworthy, and simply knows how to make someone comfortable and confident making life changing decisions. In the future, if I find myself searching for a new home again, I will contact him immediately. I am very thankful for my experience with Keith, as he made it easy to move forward with expert guidance.
"
- D.S.
"
5 Star Review
"
- G.M.
"
Keith was always ready to answer any questions I had. Was in contact with me through the whole process of selling my home and buying my new one. He works to get you the best deal. Keith is still in contact with me to check and make sure my move went smoothly. I would recommend him and Northwood Reality to everyone needing to sale or buy a home.
"
- L.C.
"
We were Very pleased with Keith Herrington, our realtor. He was always available when we needed him and put our interests first.
"
- Michael Romesburg Estate
"
5 Star Review
"
- S.R.M.E.
"
My son in law recommended Keith Herrington to list my home. I called Keith and he was very prompt in coming over and getting the process started. We listed my home on August 8 and Keith walked me through the process. He was available any time I had questions or concern. He treated me like family. I received the full asking price and we closed on October 14. I recommend him to anyone who is interested in selling or buying. He is very knowledgeable and made this easy. Thank you Keith .
"
- Roseann Rose
"
Keith Herrington was very attentive and very accessible during the promotion of my home, the sale process and as well as the closing. He was quite supportive when there issues to overcome. I appreciate all of his efforts.
"
- Mitch Ring
"
5 Star Review
"
- F.K.M.
"
Friendly’ caring person always there to answer any questions I had. He was with me through the whole process of selling my home and finding a new one. Very great full to have him as a friend
"
- C.B.
"
5 Star Review
"
- K.K.
"
Always got back to us in a manner way! Nice to work with .
"
- A.A.T.
"
Keith is the nicest guy in the world and one heck of a friend, neighbor, and real estate agent. My whole family loves Keith!
"
- Matt Eisel
"
We were very pleased with Keith Herrington as our real estate agent. He worked with us and kept us informed at all stages from beginning to end. Thank you Keith!!
"
- Charles & Sharon Zimmerman
"
Very thorough. Very willing to accommodate our needs. Very knowledgeable and a overall very nice guy.
"
- A.B.
"
I rated this at a 9 only because I would recommend Keith H but not necessarily BH because of realtor personality.
"
- Vito & Sue Virgili
"
Keith, took the time (almost a whole year at that) to help us find our forever home. He explained things that we as a young first time home buying couple did not understand and he watched out for us by being very honest about everything. I would recommend Keith to anyone. Already have to several people already. Very pleased with him and his work.
"
- Randy Calhoun
"
Easy to get along with and was available to show houses when we could see them.
"
- P.S.
"
5 Star Review
"
- D.E.S.J.
"
Keith Herrington was extremely professional, informative, accessible and helpful throughout the entire process of settling the sale of the estate property. Given my physical location of 200 miles from Waynesburg, and unexpected health issues for me and my husband, his continued and timely communications and responses to questions and concerns was most valued and appreciated. He was always accessible via phone or text, often offering to do all he could to make things as easy as possible for me which enabled me to make additional trips.
"
- Jesse Meighen/Estate
"
Keith has sold two houses and I have used him to buy two houses. He is ultimate professional, extremely knowledgable.
"
- B.A.M.
"
5 Star Review
"
- T.C.
"
Excellent knowledge very friendly yet very professional if he said he was going to do something he did it knew the realty business very well
"
- John Adams
"
Not a single issue
"
- Michael & Theresa Shimko
"
Keith was very helpful and I am thankful for all his assistance. He made the stress of selling a home much easier.
"
- Nancy Cummins
"
5 Star Review
"
- G.S.
"
Kept me updated throughout the process and welcomed my input.
"
- R.J.R.
"
Keith was very helpful and was great to work with
"
- Mike & Crystal Higgins
"
5 Star Review
"
- F.S.H.
"
5 Star Review
"
- K.D.
"
Keith was very professional and kept in close contact with me with updates and etc. I highly would recommend Keith and when I have another property to sell, I would definitely call Keith.
"
- Penny Ketchem
"
Keith was extremely helpful and gave us frequent update
"
- Lawrence Crouse/Estate
"
I’m very happy with the whole process of buying our home. Keith was available for all of our requests to see the property and kept in contact with us.
"
- Gary & Helen Wilson
"
Made everything easy for this Senior citizem
"
- Vicki Funk
"
Sold my house very quickly.
"
- M.B.E.
"
Keith went above and beyond to help my mom sell her house. He always kept my brother and I in the loop regarding showings, paperwork, etc. Keith worked hard to get my mom's house sold quickly. I would highly recommend him as a realtor.
"
- S.J.W.
"
5 Star Review
"
- W.L.I.
"
5 Star Review
"
- J.R.
"
Keith helped me both sell and buy a home. He is very knowledgeable, and was always available to provide help or answer questions. I would highly recommend him.
"
- Eleanor Welch
"
5 Star Review
"
- M.B.
MLS® Disclaimer
West Penn MLS, Inc. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumer's personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing.
The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Multiple Listing Service. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than The Keith Herrington Team may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. Copyright ©2026 All rights reserved.
Last Updated: September 26, 2026 3:17 AM UTC
Show More...
Apply today, your next place is waiting!
Request an application for this rental listing through our trusted partner, Rental Beast, and enjoy the benefits:
One-time Application Fee
Use your application with participating Rental Beast properties for 30 days with no additional cost.
Seamless Application Process
Request an application and begin yours online in seconds.
Soft Credit Check Only
A soft credit inquiry is used and does not impact your credit score.
Fast-tracked Reviews
Quick processing gets you closer to moving day, faster.
Disclaimer: By providing my phone number above and checking this box, I expressly consent to The Keith Herrington Team, directly or by a third party vendor, InsideRE, LLC, acting on The Keith Herrington Team's behalf, contacting me at this number by calling me or sending me text messages, including marketing and promotional messages, using an automatic telephone dialing system, related to our products and services for real estate transactions, even if my name appears on the "Do Not Call" list. Providing my consent is not required to obtain our products or services. Message and data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Text HELP for help or STOP to opt out.